Login  |  Register          Free Newsletter Subscription
Zibb
Subscribe to Purchasing
Email
Print
Reprint
Learn RSS

2006 Salary Survey: Purchasing paychecks get fatter

Purchasing magazine's 2006 salary survey finds that not only is compensation going up, it’s rising faster than for other professions. And women’s earnings are starting to catch up. Top management is finally recognizing smart sourcing strategy (especially for indirect) when it sees it.

By Susan Avery -- Purchasing, 12/14/2006

UPDATE: Click here to access the 2007 salary report, including salary by job title, sertification, organizational unit, experience, company size and other criteria.

It’s good to be in purchasing.

During an economic climate when most salaries are increasing at about the pace of the rate of inflation, news on compensation for purchasing professionals is good on just about every front:

  • Earnings are up 6%.
  • More buyers than ever are getting bonuses.
  • Women’s salaries are growing faster than men’s.
  • Paychecks of purchasers with responsibility for services such as travel are higher than just about anyone else’s.

All this good news is a sure sign of top management’s understanding and recognition of the profession’s value to the corporation.

Results of Purchasing’s 26th annual salary survey show compensation rising to $83,205 in 2006, a 6% increase over last year. That rate of growth is not as high as in 2005; it’s actually more in line with previous years. But the rate is higher than that for salaried workers in many other professions such as engineering and even those in careers related to the supply chain such as logistics managers.

More purchasing professionals than ever before (63%) received bonuses that average 14% of annual salary in 2006, mainly for meeting corporate financial goals, according to results of Purchasing’s survey. While the size of the bonus remains about the same, the percentage of respondents to the survey who are rewarded this way for their performance has been increasing over the past five years.

For the first time since the magazine has surveyed its readers on compensation, women’s average earnings ($66,671)—while still significantly lower than men’s ($89,956)—are growing at a faster pace (7.1%) than average (6%) and quicker still than paychecks of their male colleagues (4.7%). Last year, women’s compensation averaged $62,200, while men’s averaged $85,900.

And, purchasing professionals who are responsible for sourcing services such as human resource benefits, consulting, travel and advertising and marketing are reporting salaries that average more than $100,000 annually, a lot better than their colleagues who source other commodities. This is a continuation of yet another trend: management recognition of the tremendous impact strategic sourcing of indirect goods and services can have on the bottom line.

Bucking the trend

While the latest data from the Bureau of Labor Statistics show the unemployment rate in the U.S. at 4.4%—its lowest level since 2001—compensation for salaried workers for the most part has not started to rise, nor is it expected to do so in 2007. Results of a survey of more than 1,000 organizations earlier this year by Hewitt Associates, a human resources consulting provider in Lincolnshire, Ill., shows that salaried-exempt employees received raises of 3.6% this year. Next year, these same employees can expect raises of 3.7%, the highest increase in five years, the consultants say.

Results of salary surveys conducted by Design News and Logistics Management magazines show professionals working in positions with similar levels of responsibility to those held by respondents to Purchasing’s annual questionnaire—and similar qualifications—didn’t get big raises either. Design engineers earned an average of $73,000—a raise of 3% over last year—while salaries of logistics managers actually fell 4.5% from $83,790 to $80,000. This is a sign of a leveling off in demand for the professionals, report Logistics Management editors. Both Design News and Logistics Management magazines are published by Reed Business Information, parent company of Purchasing.

These functions are vital to the success of growing companies, so why are purchasing professionals apparently bucking the trend? Purchasing turned to recruiters for a response to that question. It’s simply a matter of supply and demand, they say.

“With the continued success of strategic procurement initiatives and the impact of quantifiable savings, companies have taken note of the millions (and billions) that their strategic purchasing and supply chain groups are saving,” says Kevin Rohan, director of procurement recruiting, J.P. Canon Associates in New York. “The end result is that companies in many industries—pharmaceutical, financial services, manufacturing, chemical processing—are all competing for the same people. It’s forced them to pay premiums to attract talent.”

Over the past eight years, Rohan has seen a 10-20% increase in salary scales for strategic purchasing professionals and the rewards for performance become much more lucrative. Purchasing/sourcing manager jobs that may have had a range of $70,000 to $90,000 six years ago now are being filled at $90,000 to $110,000 or more. Hot industries are those he mentions along with consumer food and beverage, medical devices, and financial services businesses. Companies in these industries are paying top dollar, particularly for purchasing professionals with category expertise at sourcing marketing services, IT, professional services (HR, legal, consulting), travel, facilities and capital equipment/MRO.

Crunching the numbers

To view past Purchasing salary survey results:
 
2005 Salary Survey:Applause,please

2004 Salary Survey:Bonuses thaw out

2003 Salary Survey:Purchasing pros beat inflation

2002 Salary Survey:Pace of hikes slows

2001 Salary Survey:who gets paid the most?
The average annual compensation—salaries and bonuses—of purchasing professionals responding to the 2006 salary survey is $83,205, a 6% increase ($4,705) over last year’s average ($78,500).

This year’s median salary—that point at which half the survey respondents receive more compensation and half receive less—is $71,500. That’s $2,500 greater than last year’s median ($69,000) a 3.6% increase.

The Institute for Supply Management conducted its first annual salary survey of both members and non-members in the ISM database earlier this year. Results of this study show respondents have an average annual salary of $78,470, a figure in line with Purchasing’s results reported in the December, 2005 issue.

Sixty-three percent of purchasing professionals responding to Purchasing’s 26th annual salary survey received a bonus, averaging 14%. The percentage receiving a bonus is higher than ever before in the history of the salary survey. Last year, the figure was 60%. The average size of the bonus, however, is a bit less than in previous years. In 2005, average size of bonus received by respondents was 11.9%.

Senior executives responding to the survey—including purchasing vice presidents and directors, materials managers, commodity managers, and purchasing and supply chain managers—are the most likely to receive bonuses. More than three quarters of respondents filling these titles received a bonus as part of their compensation package. Consistent with seniority, bonuses are most common among purchasing executives with the greatest supervisory and dollar-volume responsibilities.

All together, respondents received a bonus for meeting company financial goals (62%), development cost targets (18%), cost targets for purchased parts (16%), supplier quality improvements (8%) and cycle time improvements (6%).

Sixteen percent of respondents receive stock options, a figure similar to results of last year’s survey. Average stock value is $12,500.

Purchasing profile

Results of the 26th annual salary survey reflect the range of purchasing professionals who make up Purchasing’s readership. The magazine received responses from men and women filling all job titles, from buyer to chief purchasing officer (CPO). Respondents represent every region of the country, every commodity and every industry.

Purchasing’s analysis of salary according to job title spans a range of $128,600 from lowest to highest. Average compensation for buyers is $49,900. Average compensation for purchasing or supply vice presidents is $178,500. The highest paid respondent earned $600,000 in 2005. He is in middle management, and works in the wholesale, durable goods/service center industry. His main area of responsibility is metals buying.

As in past years, results of Purchasing’s annual salary survey show that a purchasing executive’s professional responsibilities serve as a benchmark of his or her compensation. As dollar volume and supervisory duties increase, so does income. The break point for higher than average earning’s in this year’s study is more than $25 million in annual purchasing responsibility. Survey respondents responsible for less than this typically report compensation close to average or less than average for the profession as a whole; those who purchase at this level and above enjoy better-than-average salaries. Similarly, as supervisory duties increase so does average pay.

The best compensated commodities for purchasing professionals are: services ($106,200), transportation/freight ($92,900) and information technology ($90,400).

Avg Buyer Sr. Buyer Purch Mgr Comm Mgr Supply Chain Mgr Mat'l Mgr Purch Mat'l Mgr VP Purch/Supply Other
Avg 83,205 49,897 64,279 76,425 84,316 103,253 82,199 118,840 178,469 84,540
Communications equipment 79.1 46.9 58.3 79.1 98.9 113.9 70.6 119.3 141.5 88.0
Computers and related equipment 85.3 41.0 78.2 83.7 88.2 93.7 76.0 113.0 176.0 91.0
Equipment/ machinery 73.5 42.5 58.6 69.3 82.9 131.7 78.1 110.4 227.3 70.5
Electronics 80.8 45.8 65.6 88.0 77.7 98.0 89.6 114.4 149.3 75.0
Energy/ mining/ utilities 88.5 51.9 70.5 99.4 86.3 101.4 83.5 124.7 172.3 84.2
Financial/ Services 85.7 45.4 61.4 78.7 71.9 73.3 70.0 127.6 137.8 82.4
Industrial controls/instruments 76.0 49.1 65.7 65.4 98.3 90.0 83.8 130.9 80.9
Miscellaneous manufacturing 80.1 52.8 61.5 74.3 85.0 98.3 81.2 120.2 165.4 76.1
Primary metals andmetals fabricating 74.8 48.5 60.0 66.7 77.3 107.9 81.3 108.6 140.0 69.1
Process Industries (chemicals/ paper/ food) 90.8 51.4 72.3 77.1 95.3 122.9 88.9 132.6 223.7 87.3
Transportation/ Automotive 83.1 49.6 66.4 83.3 78.0 72.0 79.2 127.8 180.1 79.5
Wholesale, durable goods/ service centers 89.8 50.4 67.2 70.0 64.5 94.5 82.6 109.2 149.7 108.7
Source: Purchasing

Avg Buyer Sr. Buyer Purch Mgr Comm Mgr Supply Chain Mgr Mat'l Mgr Purch Mat'l Mgr VP Purch/Supply Other
Avg 83,205 49,897 64,279 76,425 84,316 103,253 82,199 118,840 178,469 84,540
Metals 80.2 47.3 61.7 67.6 84.1 92.8 83.2 105.4 173.7 97.0
Chemicals 85.6 48.5 68.7 83.7 102.7 88.4 75.4 120.0 193.5 73.9
Electronics 84.9 49.8 62.6 83.5 86.1 107.0 75.3 120.7 193.9 87.5
Packaging 84.4 49.5 63.7 71.7 77.8 114.7 82.1 136.1 215.0 84.3
Components 79.3 54.4 60.6 71.3 75.3 92.0 86.4 124.8 199.7 78.2
Machinery 86.4 67.1 73.6 88.7 98.0 118.4 70.7 114.7 155.0 77.8
MRO 71.2 48.1 63.0 78.1 75.1 112.7 92.8 104.7 130.2 72.3
Office equipment/ supplies 71.2 37.3 61.7 64.2 81.6 93.7 100.0 85.2
Transportation/ freight 92.9 35.0 38.0 82.3 65.0 128.3 76.8 109.6 158.8 83.1
Information technology 90.4 46.3 72.1 82.8 77.3 117.5 128.8 139.6 90.8
Services (e.g. travel) 106.2 58.8 75.4 102.3 80.4 121.3 123.8 137.4 183.8 96.6
Source: Purchasing


Average Median
Salary $83,205 $71,500
Age 46 years 47 years
Years experience 16 15
Source: Purchasing

How we do it
Purchasing surveyed its readership beginning in June 2006 with a survey inserted in the issue mailed to subscribers that month. Also, an e-mail survey was sent to subscribers in July. The results were tabulated by Research Results, an independent research firm, and are based on 1,956 (454 mail-in survey and 1,502 from online survey) usable replies. At a 95% confidence level, results are accurate within a margin of error of +/-2.2%.


 

Women are beginning to catch up

Just 29% of respondents to Purchasing’s 2006 salary survey are women. This figure is slightly lower than the proportion of women included in last year’s survey. On average, women purchasing professionals earn $66,671. Men earn $89,956. Starting from a smaller base, women’s salaries rose at a faster pace than men’s; 7.1% compared to 4.7%. For comparison purposes, all salaries grew 6%.

Looked at another way, the ratio of women’s salaries to men’s also increased a bit. According to results of the salary survey, women purchasers now earn 74¢ for every dollar men earn. This is more than last year when this figure was 72¢, but still below average figures provided by the U.S. Census Bureau that show women earning 77¢ for every dollar men earn.

Tonia Deal, president of Tonia Deal Consultants in Hudson, Ohio, says women’s salaries are starting to increase at a faster pace because of the value corporations place on the purchasing function today. When Deal, who has 14 years’ experience placing purchasing professionals in executive roles, negotiates compensation for a client, she says previous earnings play little role in determining starting salary and bonus.

“I need to know where the candidate is today up front,” she says. “But I look at his or her current value to the organization. If I am presenting a female candidate that I feel very confident about, I am going to get her compensation to market average or above.”

The highest salary earned by a female respondent to this year’s survey is $366,000. (The highest salary earned by a man is $600,00, a difference of $234,000.) She is one of 66 women who report annual average earnings of $100,000 or more. This executive is a vice president of purchasing at a manufacturing company; her main commodity responsibility is electronics. She has a degree in business, but doesn’t hold a CPM. She has worked in purchasing for more than 10 years.

Historically, women in purchasing are younger and less experienced than men. As in previous years, women respondents have fewer supervisory responsibilities, are in charge of smaller dollar volumes, have less frequently graduated from college, are younger than men and do not often hold senior level positions as men—all prerequisites for higher compensation. Even when these factors are taken into consideration, and men and women with comparable experience and responsibilities are compared, average compensation among women generally appears to be less than the average compensation among men in the profession.

Average salary
Avg Men Women
Avg 83,205 89,956 66,671
VP, Purchasing/ Supply/ CPO 178.5 180.0 169.1
(NET) Sr. Mgmt 134.3 137.2 119.0
Purchasing/ Materials director 118.8 121.9 101.9
Supply chain manager 103.3 107.2 87.8
Other 84.5 94.4 64.3
Commodity manager 84.3 85.9 79.4
Materials manager 82.2 83.0 77.9
(NET) Middle Mgmt 82.1 86.1 70.7
Purchasing manager 76.4 77.9 72.2
Sr. Buyer 64.3 66.4 60.4
(NET) Buyer 57.0 60.8 51.7
Buyer 49.9 53.9 45.8
Source: Purchasing

Related articles:

Building a strategic supply chain? Don't forget purchasing professionals with materials skills

UTC backs its purchasing professionals with educational resources

Buyers are red hot

More pencils, books forecast in the supply chain

Market for purchasing execs takes off

Email
Print
Reprint
Learn RSS

Related Content

Related Content

 

By This Author

Sponsored Links

 
Advertisement
Sponsored Links

More Content

  • Blogs
  • Purchlive

Blogs

  • Richard G. Weissman
    Back to School

    December 1, 2008
    Supplier Relationships: Now More Than Ever
    The "bunker mentality" that seems to be permeating business these days will destroy most of the supply management gains made in the past ......
    More
  • View All BlogsRSS
Advertisements





NEWSLETTERS

Click on a title below to learn more.

Resource Center E-Alert (Monthly)
Price + Supply Alert (Weekly)
Monday Midday Business Report (Weekly)
Electronics Distribution and Global Sourcing (Monthly)
IdeaFile (Twice Monthly)
Supplier Web Locator (4x/year)
About Us   |   Advertising Info   |   Site Map   |   Contact Us   |   FREE Subscription   |   RSS
© 2008 Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Use of this Web site is subject to its Terms of Use | Privacy Policy
Please visit these other Reed Business sites